Skip to Main Content

Four emerging cyber risks to consider before placing coverage

Cyber losses don’t always involve a hacker breaking into a company’s network—and insurance doesn’t respond to every scenario in the same way.


By Raphael Da Costa

Senior Director, Cyber, Markel Insurance | 

6-minute read

A combination of agentic artificial intelligence (AI), interconnected vendors and privacy disputes are changing what businesses need from cyber insurance. Exposures created or intensified by new technologies and practices are changing legal obligations and loss scenarios that businesses previously underestimated.

For those considering cyber insurance, the starting point is practical: understand how the technology is used, identify what could disrupt their operations and connect those exposures to specific policy language. While actual coverage depends on policy terms, facts and applicable law, here are four emerging cyber risks and some general guidance to help those looking to place coverage.

1. AI-enabled fraud and technology liability

AI can make phishing messages more convincing, such as using synthetic audio or video that impersonates a trusted person. An employee might receive what appears to be an executive’s voice instruction to transfer money and act, causing the business to potentially incur damages without suffering a conventional network breach.

Ask whether social engineering (i.e., deception that persuades someone to act) and fraudulent transfers are covered under your cyber policy, a separate crime policy or neither. Check payment-verification conditions and any separate limits. Do not assume coverage of “computer fraud” addresses every impersonation scenario.

Additionally, a client’s own AI use also matters. Agentic AI systems can pursue goals through multiple actions with limited human direction; giving them access to customer records or business systems can create questions about permissions, oversight and accountability.

Map the alleged harm to the coverage. A client’s faulty technology service may raise technology errors and omissions, or tech E&O, questions. And remember: a privacy breach may raise additional cyber questions, so careful review of AI-related wording is essential rather than assuming all AI losses are covered or excluded.

Article highlights

  • Cyber losses don't always start with a breach.
  • Your client's vendors may be part of their cyber exposure.
  • AI is changing the questions worth asking.
  • Policy wording matters more as risks overlap.
  • Better placement starts with understanding how the client actually operates.

For those considering cyber insurance, the starting point is practical: understand how the technology is used, identify what could disrupt their operations and connect those exposures to specific policy language.

2. Vendor failures and outages without an attacker

Businesses increasingly depend on cloud platforms, payment processors and outside IT providers to function. A breach at one supplier can affect many customers, as can an accidental outage: the July 2024 CrowdStrike incident demonstrated how a software update could disrupt operations without a malicious attack, and similar incidents are on the rise.

Contingent business interruption can cover qualifying income loss caused by disruption at a covered third-party provider. The key words are “qualifying” and “covered”; check which providers fall within the definition and whether coverage requires a security incident or also includes non-malicious system failure.

During initial inquiry, ask clients which unavailable service would stop them from trading. Then examine waiting periods, restoration periods and sublimits. These dependencies also create accumulation risk: one event can generate multiple claims across many insured businesses. Scenario estimates help test limits but cannot predict every interconnected loss; review widespread-event restrictions and war-related exclusions, including their triggers.

Reviewing only network security can miss exposure.

3. Privacy claims that do not require a breach

Even when a business has its systems working as intended, it can face privacy allegations. Disputes can concern consent and data collection, not stolen records, and a website or email’s tracking pixels may share personal information with advertising or analytics providers without a business’s knowledge.

Reviewing only network security can miss exposure—try to involve marketing, legal and IT teams in identifying any tracking tools, customer information collected and third parties that might receive it.

For placement, examine whether privacy liability includes wrongful collection or disclosure without a security failure. Review tracking-related exclusions, defense coverage and treatment of statutory damages. Fines, penalties and other amounts may be uninsurable under applicable law; never promise that a privacy liability limit covers every regulatory consequence.

4. Ransomware, disclosure and executive accountability

Ransomware remains an important consideration, as extortion can now involve threats to publish stolen information without encrypting systems. Backups may help restore operations but cannot undo data theft; review cyber extortion, incident response, restoration and business interruption provisions separately.

Regulatory obligations add another layer. Domestic SEC registrants generally must disclose material cybersecurity incidents within four business days after determining materiality—not just four days after discovery. Other notification duties depend on the business and relevant jurisdictions.

Additionally, executive liability can add additional risk to evolving incidents. These types of claims involve allegations against directors or officers, potentially including failures in oversight or disclosure. Coordinated cyber and D&O coverage is a stronger choice than assuming one policy will cover it all; inaccurate representations can create coverage disputes and gaps.

You do not need to become a cybersecurity engineer to lead a useful conversation.

Turn emerging risks into a stronger placement

While these risks test the legal and organizational limits of coverage, they also present an opportunity to strengthen existing protocols and initiatives. You do not need to become a cybersecurity engineer to lead a useful conversation; instead, consider these five actions:

  • Map the exposure. Identify critical systems, sensitive information, AI uses and vendor dependencies. Include the people responsible for technology, finance, legal compliance and marketing in the conversation.
  • Test realistic scenarios. Imagine several days without a key provider, a fraudulent payment and stolen customer records. Estimate lost income, recovery costs and liability expenses with the client based on their operational knowledge.
  • Evaluate the response needed. Establish reporting contacts and any requirements for insurer consent or approved service providers before an incident. For brokers placing coverage, consider important factors like the financial strength, cyber underwriting expertise, incident-response access and claims support behind the agreement.
  • Compare wording carefully. Review covered events, vendor definitions, sublimits, retentions and exclusions. Request clarification or narrower wording where available and document unresolved gaps.
  • Think beyond the coverage. Discuss multifactor authentication, protected backups, endpoint monitoring, payment verification and response exercises. Confirm actual controls rather than assuming they exist—and empower your client to remain proactive in their cybersecurity.

The goal is to understand which losses the client could face, which the insurer will accept and which remain with the business. Revisit those decisions with the addition of new technologies, vendor changes or operational shifts—not just at renewal. With cyber risks evolving rapidly, strong partnerships pave the way for stronger customer resilience and quicker recovery.

Become a Markel Insider

Subscribe to "The Ins—your go-to source for the ins and outs of the US & Bermuda insurance industry, now available as a LinkedIn newsletter.

Related US insurance offerings

Business insurance

Markel offers a wide range of insurance solutions for middle market and large businesses, with coverage tailored to meet each customer's unique needs and risks.

Industries

With deep industry expertise, we provide innovative solutions tailored to address the unique risks and needs of businesses and industries of all sizes.

  • Small business
  • Cyber
  • Professional and financial risks
  • Broker insight