Skip to Main Content

Navigating a more nuanced Financial Institutions insurance market

A rise in new risks has made the Financial Institutions insurance market more complex than ever. We looked at the challenges faced by banks, fintechs, private credit and more to share what they mean for Financial Institutions insurance providers.


Travis Pearson, Managing Director, PLL, Financial Institutions
Deb Chamian, Sr. Director, Financial Institutions

6-minute read


The Financial Institutions (FI) insurance market is becoming increasingly segmented. A combination of shifting economic pressures, uncertain regulatory environments, fresh technology and new market entrants has created a growing pace of change in the industry, making nuanced, rigorous underwriting even more necessary.

The fact that FI organisations no longer share common risk profiles is a core example of these changes. However, there may be many opportunities for brokers and underwriters to adapt to these changing market conditions, particularly where FI insurance offerings can also evolve to become increasingly targeted to customer needs.

For underwriters looking to pivot and grow, the necessary starting point is to deeply understand these shifts. The differences between traditional banks, modern fintech and non-bank lender insurances have expanded; add in private credit and the changing role of asset managers, and the market feels more fragmented than ever.

To understand what’s happening and what’s on the horizon, let’s look at each FI insurance market segment individually.

Article highlights

  • FI risks are increasingly fragmented
  • Banks face shifting pressures
  • Fintech growth creates new challenges
  • Private credit is under the spotlight
  • Underwriting must evolve

Banks: Managing stability and regulatory expectations

Banks are facing shifting interest rates and liquidity challenges, as well as pressure from adjusting credit quality within key client bases. Oversight requirements also differ significantly across institutions based on size and geography, creating an irregular playing field that requires client-specific attention.

The takeaway: for FI market underwriters, resilience planning and governance are key to securing financial strength. Effective and evolving cyber controls are also an important consideration, given the constant monitoring and response required for cyber risk at financial institutions. Maintaining awareness of a bank’s unique pain points, as well as the general pressures of the market, is essential for disciplined underwriting.

Financial institutions no longer share common risk profiles, making nuanced, rigorous underwriting more necessary than ever.

Non-bank lenders: Growth paired with structural sensitivities

The role of non-bank lenders also continues to expand in both consumer and commercial lending markets. Their funding models, despite the agility they provide, can be more sensitive to funding availability and market conditions than traditional, time-served banks.

Non-bank lenders often have efficient, lean operations, which can require exceptional fraud prevention and internal controls. Without these, a compelling growth story may become hampered by burgeoning risks.

The takeaway: savvy underwriters should regularly research a non-bank lender’s funding model, appetite and proactive fraud detection.

Fintech: Balancing innovation with operational resilience

Fintech is a significant success story in a digitised, fast-moving market and has a risk profile synonymous with rapid scaling, platform-dependent business models and reliance on third-party vendors.

The fintech regulatory environment varies greatly by jurisdiction, raising key questions about customer safety and regulatory control in an unsettled market.

The takeaway: to underwrite in this space, underwriters should know how providers are handling and managing customer data, with particular attention to compliance, which cyber controls are in place for security, how their provided service is kept stable and how mature the brand's governance approach has proven to be.

Asset managers: Navigating market volatility

Valuation pressure and performance swings are driving exposure for asset managers, at a time when increasing demand for responsible investment practices is reshaping the segment. Customers, partners and regulators want to see evidence that these practices are both transparent and responsible, and asset managers are feeling increased liability and scrutiny.

Responsible asset managers should also recognise and address the multiple operational risks associated with tech-driven workflows. Digital trading systems, secure data handling and the need for timely investor communication make the job more complex.

The takeaway: a customer-centric approach to underwriting relies on a holistic view of risk management, with special attention to the potential social backswing against their portfolio or practices.

Segmentation is no longer just a framework for the FI market—it is an opportunity to build customer satisfaction and meaningful competitive advantage.

Private credit risk: Rising demand and increasing scrutiny

As traditional bank lending has tightened in some markets, private credit has grown to meet demand in new, innovative ways.

The takeaway: underwriters may need to consider multiple factors including leverage, regulatory dynamics and the broader challenge of valuing and assessing liquidity in these private markets.

What does this mean for underwriters and brokers?

As the industry continues to evolve rapidly, underwriters and brokers are under increasing pressure to stay informed and understand the potential impact of these developments, particularly in areas such as:

  • Cloud security and cyber risk in financial institutions.
  • Ongoing mitigation of fraud risk in financial services.
  • Financial institution regulatory compliance.
  • Broader economic volatility and its uneven effects on target markets.

With the FI market no longer operating as a single category, it's important to:

  • Carry out tailored, targeted assessments to enable confident underwriting.
  • Focus on developing clear and timely communication between brokers and underwriters.
  • Segment carefully to adequately address the different target markets’ characteristics.

Markel's response to a changing Fl insurance market

Each FI subsector has its own regulatory, structural and operational characteristics that don’t work with the old “one size fits all” approach. In this way, segmentation moves beyond a framework and becomes an opportunity to develop both customer satisfaction and meaningful competitive advantage in the market.

Markel employs a feedback loop and reassessment model to maintain a responsive, disciplined approach that genuinely meets changing client needs. We're also proud to serve tightly segmented markets, from community bank insurance to small business insurance, with bespoke offers that demonstrate how we continually evolve to better serve our customers. We’re committed to aligning closely with brokers and policyholders as part of our disciplined underwriting approach, so that they receive high-quality service with careful risk management and excellent communication.

  • Financial institutions
  • Professional and financial risks
  • Broker insight